Since the release of their first album, Dark Water, in 2020, Rev Dave and the Sin Eaters have received two MusicNL nominations for Folk/ Roots Artist of the year and two ECMA nominations for their 2022 album, Beams of Love, which was nominated in both the Blues and Country Categories.  In 2024 the group released, Live at the Garrick Theatre, an 18 song double album with accompanying video.

Since its inception the band has served as a vehicle for collaboration with fine musicians from across NL: Tom Brennan, Dan Hiltz, Dave Barry, Louis McDonald, Scott Sheppard, Darryl Perrett, Andrea Monro, Kev Hamilton, Noah Hamilton, Wade Pinhorn and Craig Young.

2025 will see the release of Lost and Found which will see the band lean into its country roots.